PERISCOPE DEPTHWHYARIUM NO. 95
← WHYARIUM
COMPARTMENT 10 · BOATS THAT DID NOT COME BACK

Eternal Patrol

Submariners say a boat that never came home is still on patrol. These are nine of them, told plainly: what is known, what is still disputed, and what was changed afterwards so that other crews would come back.

Every navy that has sent boats to sea has lost some. The nine here are well known because of what they taught. Between them, 674 people did not come home, and in one of them 33 were brought up alive.

  1. 17 February 1864

    H. L. Hunley

    8 lost
    Off Charleston, South Carolina, USA (about 4-5 miles offshore)

    On the night of 17 February 1864 the hand-powered Confederate submarine H. L. Hunley sank the Union sloop USS Housatonic off Charleston with a charge on a long spar; five of Housatonic's crew died. Hunley never returned, and all eight men aboard, commanded by Lt. George E. Dixon, were lost. It was the boat's third sinking: five men died in a training accident in August 1863 and eight, including Horace Hunley, in October 1863, so 21 crew died in all. Why it sank is still debated: theories include the crew being injured by the blast of their own charge, a lack of air, or flooding. The wreck was found in 1995 and raised in 2000, and the crew were buried with honours in Charleston in 2004.

    Cause

    Disputed

    Afterwards

    The first sinking of a warship by a submarine showed what submarines could do, but also their dangers; the raised wreck is now a major archaeology and conservation project.

  2. 1 June 1939

    HMS Thetis

    99 lost · 4 saved
    Liverpool Bay, England, in about 46 m (150 ft) of water

    On 1 June 1939, during her first trial dive, the new submarine HMS Thetis flooded through a torpedo tube and sank bow-first in Liverpool Bay with 103 men aboard, many of them shipyard workers and observers. Her stern stayed near the surface for hours, but rescue efforts failed. Four men escaped using the aft escape chamber; 99 died.

    Cause

    Flooding through a torpedo tube during a trial dive: the inner door of tube No. 5 was opened while its outer door was open to the sea. A test drain meant to warn of this was blocked by enamel paint. How the outer door came to be open was never fully established.

    Afterwards

    A latch known as the 'Thetis clip' was added so that a torpedo tube's inner door could only open a little at first and be shut again if water came in, and torpedo tubes on British and Australian submarines were redesigned. The boat was salvaged, renamed HMS Thunderbolt, and was lost with all hands in March 1943.

  3. 23 May 1939

    USS Squalus

    26 lost · 33 saved
    Off the Isles of Shoals, near Portsmouth, New Hampshire, USA, in 74 m (243 ft) of water

    On 23 May 1939, during a test dive, the main air intake of the new submarine USS Squalus failed to close and the after compartments flooded; 26 men drowned. The 33 survivors in the forward part of the boat (32 crew and one civilian) were brought up in four trips by the McCann rescue chamber, a diving bell that sealed onto the escape hatch, directed by Lt. Cdr. Charles 'Swede' Momsen. It was the first successful use of a rescue chamber to save men from a sunken submarine.

    Cause

    Failure of the main induction valve (the large air intake for the engines) during a test dive, flooding the after part of the boat.

    Afterwards

    The rescue proved the McCann chamber and helium-oxygen breathing mixtures for deep divers. Squalus was raised, renamed USS Sailfish, and served with distinction in World War II; her conning tower is a memorial at Portsmouth Naval Shipyard.

  4. 10 April 1963

    USS Thresher (SSN-593)

    129 lost
    North Atlantic, about 190-220 nmi east of Cape Cod, Massachusetts, USA; wreck at about 2,600 m

    On 10 April 1963, during deep-diving trials after an overhaul, the nuclear submarine USS Thresher was lost with all 129 aboard: 112 crew and 17 civilian technicians and observers. Her escort ship heard garbled messages before contact ended. The Navy's court of inquiry concluded that a piping joint probably failed, leading to flooding, loss of propulsion and an unsuccessful attempt to surface. It remains the deadliest submarine loss in US history. The Navy began releasing the inquiry records in 2020.

    Cause

    Officially: probable failure of a silver-brazed seawater piping joint, causing flooding; the reactor shut down, and ice forming in the air system stopped the crew from blowing the ballast tanks.

    Afterwards

    The Navy created the SUBSAFE program in December 1963, which strictly certifies hull, piping and ballast systems. No SUBSAFE-certified submarine has been lost since. The loss also launched deep-submergence rescue and search programs.

  5. 22 May 1968

    USS Scorpion (SSN-589)

    99 lost
    Atlantic Ocean, about 400 nmi southwest of the Azores; wreck at about 3,000 m

    The nuclear submarine USS Scorpion was lost with all 99 crew in late May 1968 while returning to Norfolk, Virginia from the Mediterranean. Its wreck was located in October 1968 on the seabed southwest of the Azores. The Navy's court of inquiry could not determine a certain cause; it ruled out sabotage and described an event that led to uncontrolled flooding. Proposed explanations include a hydrogen explosion in the battery and an accidental torpedo problem.

    Cause

    Disputed. The court of inquiry said the cause 'cannot be ascertained' from the evidence; theories include a battery or torpedo explosion and a mechanical failure.

    Afterwards

    Scorpion had not received the full SUBSAFE work during her 1967 overhaul, which added weight to SUBSAFE's importance. The search also became a famous example of using probability methods to find lost objects at sea.

  6. 8 March 1968

    Soviet submarine K-129

    98 lost
    North Pacific, about 1,560 nmi northwest of Oahu, Hawaii

    The Soviet diesel-electric ballistic-missile submarine K-129 sank in early March 1968 with all 98 crew while on patrol in the North Pacific. The Soviet Navy searched without finding it. In 1974 the US Central Intelligence Agency, in the secret Project Azorian, used a specially built ship to lift part of the wreck from about 5,000 m; part broke away during the lift. The remains of six sailors recovered were buried at sea with military honours in September 1974.

    Cause

    Disputed. The Soviet Navy's view was that the boat went below safe depth while snorkelling and flooded; other theories include a battery explosion, a missile accident, or a collision (denied by the US).

    Afterwards

    In 1992 the US gave Russia a video of the 1974 burial ceremony. The recovery remains one of the most ambitious deep-sea salvage efforts ever attempted.

  7. 12 August 2000

    K-141 Kursk

    118 lost
    Barents Sea, about 135 km from Severomorsk, Russia, in 108 m of water

    During a naval exercise on 12 August 2000, two explosions sank the Russian nuclear submarine Kursk in the Barents Sea. Most of the 118 men aboard died at once, but 23 survived for some hours in the stern compartment, as a note by Captain-Lieutenant Dmitri Kolesnikov showed. Russian rescue attempts failed, and offers of foreign help were at first declined; Norwegian and Russian divers opened the rescue hatch on 21 August and found no one alive. Most of the hull was raised in 2001 and the crew's remains recovered.

    Cause

    Officially (Russian government investigation): a leak of high-test peroxide fuel from a faulty practice torpedo caused an explosion, which set off further torpedo warheads about two minutes later.

    Afterwards

    The disaster led to closer international cooperation on submarine rescue, including the International Submarine Escape and Rescue Liaison Office, set up in 2003 with Russian participation. In 2005, the crew of the Russian mini-submarine AS-28 was rescued with British help.

  8. 15 November 2017

    ARA San Juan

    44 lost
    South Atlantic, about 430-500 km off the coast of Argentina; wreck at 907 m

    The Argentine diesel-electric submarine ARA San Juan lost contact on 15 November 2017 while returning to Mar del Plata, after reporting that water had entered a battery compartment and caused a small fire. Hours later, underwater listening stations recorded a sound consistent with an implosion. All 44 crew were lost, including Eliana Krawczyk, Argentina's first female submarine officer. After a long international search, the wreck was found on 16-17 November 2018 at a depth of 907 m.

    Cause

    Partly established: the crew had reported seawater entering through the ventilation (snorkel) system into a battery compartment, causing a short circuit and fire; the boat later imploded. Responsibility is disputed.

    Afterwards

    A 2019 congressional commission blamed senior navy leadership and underfunding, and rejected the idea of an attack; the report was not unanimous. In 2026 a federal court convicted the former head of the submarine force of negligence and acquitted three other former senior officers; appeals were possible.

  9. 21 April 2021

    KRI Nanggala (402)

    53 lost
    Bali Sea, about 95 km north of Bali, Indonesia; wreck at about 838 m

    The Indonesian diesel-electric submarine KRI Nanggala lost contact during a torpedo exercise on 21 April 2021 in the Bali Sea. Ships and aircraft from several countries joined the search, and a Singaporean rescue vessel's underwater robot found the wreck broken into three parts at about 838 m. All 53 people aboard were lost. The Indonesian Navy suggested the boat suffered a power loss and sank below its safe depth; a large internal wave, a known feature of these waters, was proposed as a possible factor but has not been confirmed.

    Cause

    Disputed / not fully determined. Navy officials suggested a power failure and raised the possibility of a strong internal wave; other experts pointed to the age and condition of the 1980-built boat.

    Afterwards

    The crew were posthumously promoted and honoured. The loss led to calls in Indonesia to modernize the submarine fleet and its maintenance.

Numbers and causes are from the official inquiries where they exist and from the sources on the About page. Where an inquiry could not find the cause, we say so rather than guess.

Other compartments